Karachi’s TRACS Faces Criticism Over Fines and Poor Road Conditions
The Sindh government’s new Karachi traffic system, called TRACS, has triggered strong public backlash. Citizens, experts, and opposition parties say the government rushed its launch without fixing poor roads and broken traffic signals.
According to the Chief Minister’s House, the Traffic Regulation and Citation System began on October 27. It uses CCTV cameras and AI to detect violations. The system issues digital e-challans that can be paid or appealed online. First-time offenders get a one-time waiver.
Officials said TRACS aims to curb reckless driving and promote traffic discipline. Over 200 cameras are active now, and the network will expand to 12,000.
Public Anger Over High Fines
Many citizens call the fines excessive. They range from Rs5,000 for motorcyclists to Rs100,000 for heavy vehicles. Offences include speeding, signal-jumping, and driving without a licence. Residents say the system feels unfair when Karachi’s roads remain broken.
Activist Naeem Khan warned that e-challans often go to old vehicle owners. Political parties also objected. The Central Muslim League challenged the fines in court, calling them discriminatory. MQM-P and Jamaat-e-Islami leaders described TRACS as “anti-Karachi,” demanding reforms.
Officials Defend TRACS Initiative
Sindh Minister Saeed Ghani defended the system, saying it aims to save lives, not punish citizens. He urged drivers to follow traffic rules.
However, experts warn that without road repairs, working signals, and better awareness, TRACS may fail. Karachi has millions of vehicles, many still unregistered. Urban planners stress that infrastructure must improve before digital enforcement can succeed.
