Do Not Ban Social Media for Under-16s, Says School Head

Calls to ban social media for under-16s continue to grow. However, one head teacher believes a total ban is the wrong solution. Tony McCabe, head of St Joseph’s High School in Greater Manchester, urges balance.
He says social media brings risks, but it also offers real benefits. According to McCabe, social media helps young people stay connected. It also supports learning, collaboration, and mental wellbeing.

Why a Blanket Ban Misses the Point

Recently, more than 60 MPs backed restrictions on under-16s using social platforms. In addition, some parents support bans similar to Australia’s new law. McCabe disagrees with this approach. He believes it oversimplifies a complex issue.
For example, many students use social platforms to revise together. They also encourage one another during stressful times. As a result, banning access could remove positive support systems. Instead, McCabe calls for smarter supervision and education.

Education, Monitoring, and Shared Responsibility

McCabe agrees that phones should stay out of classrooms.
However, he stresses that schools must teach responsible online behaviour. Schools already use monitoring and filtering tools. These systems flag harmful searches and alert staff quickly. Therefore, McCabe questions why social media companies cannot do the same.
He believes platforms should help identify and support vulnerable users. At the same time, he acknowledges real concerns.
Social media can shorten attention spans and encourage addictive habits.
Algorithms, in particular, can expose young users to harmful content. As a result, families must stay involved. McCabe encourages parents to talk openly with their children.
He advises listening without judgment and offering support.
Ultimately, he believes guidance works better than bans. With the right balance, social media can remain a positive force.