Pakistan Court Upholds Book Import Ban on India and Israel
Pakistan’s top court has upheld the Pakistan book import ban on India and Israel. The ruling confirms the government’s authority over such decisions. As a result, restrictions on book imports will remain in place.
The Federal Constitutional Court issued a detailed 21-page judgment. Justice Aamer Farooq authored the decision. He stated that the right to read is not absolute under the law.
The court explained that this right comes from Article 9 of the Constitution of Pakistan. However, authorities can limit it through legal provisions. Therefore, the government can impose restrictions when necessary.
Government Authority and Legal Grounds
The court supported the government’s use of SROs 927 and 928(I)/2019. Officials issued these orders based on national security and foreign policy concerns. In addition, the court recognized the government’s sovereign authority.
Judges stated that foreign policy falls under executive control. Therefore, courts cannot review such matters in detail. This limits judicial interference in sensitive decisions.
The ruling also referred to Article 97 of the Constitution of Pakistan. This article allows the federation to regulate trade within its powers. As a result, the government can restrict imports when needed.
Court Reinforces Executive Powers
The court noted that the Lahore High Court had earlier upheld the same SROs. However, it had issued additional directions later challenged by the government. The top court reviewed and clarified those points.
Judges emphasized that national security and foreign affairs remain executive matters. Therefore, courts usually avoid вмешعات in such areas. This approach protects the balance of power.
Overall, the decision strengthens the government’s authority in policy matters. It also confirms limits on individual rights under certain conditions.
